Connect with us

Feature Destination

New century, new approach to marine planning in B.C.

New century, new approach to marine planning in B.C.

Marine Planning Partnership Covers

SUMMARY: For the first time in British Columbia’s history, First Nations have been equal partners with the provincial government in developing marine use plans – a historic approach viewed largely by all involved as having yielded very positive outcomes. Beyond the promise of achieving real and lasting impact in shared marine spaces, there are broader lessons for planning and engagement that can be applied in other parts of Canada and globally.

In British Columbia, a unique approach to developing marine plans has involved a spirit of collaboration. The Marine Plan Partnership for the North Pacific Coast, or MaPP as it’s more commonly known, involves the Province and 17 member First Nations — represented by the North Coast–Skeena First Nations Stewardship Society, Coastal First Nations–Great Bear Initiative, Council of the Haida Nation, Central Coast Indigenous Resource Alliance and Nanwakolas Council. The partnership’s mandate is about planning for marine uses, economic sustainability and the long-term ocean health on B.C.’s North Pacific Coast, divided into four sub-regions: Haida Gwaii, North Coast, Central Coast and North Vancouver Island.

This collaborative approach integrates provincial government policy with First Nations governance systems, cultural practices and Indigenous and scientific knowledge. With a rich and complex history that could have otherwise resulted in lengthy delays and barriers to progress, instead this made-in-B.C. approach has realized solid working relationships and real progress in the five years since a founding letter of intent was signed in 2011.

The MaPP initiative culminated in the official signing of marine plan implementation agreements in early August 2016. With completed plans and agreements in place for the area and its four sub-regions, there is now a clear roadmap and commitment to joint implementation going forward.

The marine planning backdrop

The marine plans achieved through the unique MaPP approach are a combination of provincial and local government policy, First Nations interests and values, traditional and local knowledge and marine science. They also integrate First Nations traditional values and current legal and political perspectives.

The plans come at a time when the legal landscape is shifting, the result of a variety of factors that include: evolving legal definitions for Aboriginal fishing rights, now defined by pre-contact activities and practices; the protected right to fish for food, social or ceremonial purposes; and commercial fishing rights in certain nation-specific cases.

Meanwhile, broader legal drivers are also at play. They include evolving case law, which has opened the doors for First Nations engagement and co-leadership in activities that were typically provincial or federal government-led in the past; a requirement for prior consultation with affected First Nation Peoples; and the expectation for up-front negotiation and agreement in planning and management, now the new norm.

Understanding the approach

With increasing commercial, industrial and recreational activity along the British Columbia coast, the need for marine planning to help guide decisions about ocean use became increasingly clear.

The area involved is vast, encompassing about 102,000 square kilometres of ocean and 29,000 kilometres of coastline — an area that includes the traditional territories of the 17 First Nations’ partners, stretching along two-thirds of the North Pacific Coast of B.C.

MaPP focuses on common First Nations and provincial marine interests where the Province considers that it has legal jurisdiction and regulatory authority.

The MaPP approach and its emphasis on collaboration has stemmed from decades of resource planning (in B.C. and other parts of Canada) that has evolved towards more concerted planning involving First Nations governments. Fundamental to this approach has been the provincial government’s official recognition that First Nations are not simply stakeholders like other individuals or groups, but full-fledged, equal nation-to-nation partners.

This understanding and the relationships built through MaPP represent a critical milestone, with First Nations partners undertaking significant work to prepare for this process and, in many ways, leading on information-gathering, scientific analysis and policy development. Indeed, the precedent MaPP has set is being upheld as an international example of governance and marine spatial planning.

Various factors have not only distinguished the MaPP approach, but contributed greatly to its success.

The geographic scale alone and the number and collaboration of First Nations (in the past, perhaps one or two) coupled with the number of stakeholders engaged was unprecedented in a marine plan.

That the process was designed within a collaborative governance arrangement and involved so many nations was a major first. Such extensive First Nations participation, with nations working together and co-leading the marine planning process with the provincial government, had never before been achieved.

MaPP’s approach to funding was also integral, employing a quasi public-private partnership model that leveraged government and First Nations resources, as well as external resources from private foundations.

The diversity of stakeholders MaPP has brought together and number of marine uses, activities and values it has addressed – and will continue addressing – also distinguishes it from other processes. Among the many planning issues considered: marine science, coastal forestry, commercial and marine tourism, public recreation, finfish and shellfish aquaculture, marine conservation and infrastructure, fish processing, and renewable and non-renewable energy.

More keys to success, lessons learned

There are additional factors the MaPP partners credit to the approach’s success, which they also consider lessons learned.

A major benefit was that everyone involved understood they were at a unique point in time, as mandates and public interest can quickly change while resourcing can go away at any time. Accordingly, opportunities to achieve progress were fully leveraged.

Having the right arrangements and expertise in place was crucial. With proper governance structures and funding already established, the MaPP partnership could quickly undertake its work.

Being able to tap into an abundance of local experts made a real difference. The MaPP process was fortunate to be able to draw on resources in the form of staffing and localized expertise from within the partner organizations.

Having buy-in from stakeholders and local governments, supported by adequate funding to ensure they could engage meaningfully in the process, was critical. Also, establishing the engagement process in advance, ensured a solid, common understanding by project partners of how stakeholders would be engaged over a two-year period.

That plans were developed using a hybrid approach, having both strategic and operational components (where plans would typically be one or the other) – a major benefit. This gave regulators, decision-makers, stakeholders and the public a wide operating policy framework as a foundation.

Considerable flexibility built into the MaPP’s administration and overall project management allowed for much-valued nimbleness, both for organizational and process purposes.

All four MaPP plans used the same zoning approach, which included recommended use tables for each zone and sub-zone. The tables direct managers on how to address applications that are received for a zone’s marine uses and activities. When an application is made, it is referred to both local government and First Nations. This saves considerable time and effort by screening out marine uses from a complex review process – welcome news to First Nations and local governments alike.

Marine management took a significant step forward, with the completion of plans under the Marine Planning Partnership (MaPP) for the North Pacific Coast; a co-led partnership between BC and 18 coastal Nations. Click the image to learn more.

Challenges and complexities

If the process was to be revisited, the consensus is it would have been better to put additional staff and resources into pre-implementation planning much earlier as it is easy to become so focused on planning that implementation becomes more an after-thought. In this case, implementation agreements were being prepared about eight months before the plans were finalized – a timeframe which proved less than ideal. Once the marine plans were completed, it took a year before some parties were sufficiently comfortable with the implementation agreements to sign them. In the interim, implementation activities were identified and advanced so momentum could be maintained and progress could be demonstrated while collective agreements were refined.

Other significant lessons learned include recognition that good process builds relationships that will outlast current information, science and policy, and that the deliberate effort to reflect First Nations cultural values, governance systems and stewardship obligations leads not only to balanced plans but also greater awareness, understanding and sensitivity by non-Aboriginal stakeholder groups. In B.C., where both First Nations and the Province assert ownership of the marine and coastal areas, this approach reflects a new planning reality as well as provincial government policy.

Some specific challenges and complexities faced during the planning phase included:

  • how to identify and zone areas for marine protection without committing to specific legal designations under provincial legislation;
  • how to address marine and coastal resource management issues that were only indirectly within the mandates of participating governments, First Nations and stakeholder groups;
  • how to link broad, strategic objectives and strategies of the plans with specific area-based zoning direction and recommended use tables;
  • how to draft strategies so that they can readily be translated into measurable actions to gauge plan implementation success and to indicate ecosystem changes in the planning areas.

A new model for planning and policymaking

The marine plans developed through the MaPP partnership reflect a careful balance of planning, policy, science, First Nations tradition and more. The approach has been about applying creative, incremental solutions to areas where there were policy deficiencies.

Many issues faced by the provincial and First Nations governments, including jurisdiction, authority and governance, history and the impacts of past decisions and the importance of economy, culture and environment, can be found in other geographies.

Indeed, some of the tools developed and successfully used in MaPP are already at work in marine planning well beyond B.C. For example, a compatibility matrix, master list of definitions, allowable activities tables and rationale tables are either being used or developed for application in the Seychelles. Also in the Seychelles: a process for stakeholder input and review is being modelled after MaPP, while lessons learned are providing valuable guidance in key areas such as the importance of government-to-government partnerships and leveraging timelines to maintain momentum.

MaPP is a success story about how collaborative planning can work across a very large area that encompasses many different communities, a complex geography with hundreds upon hundreds of inlets and bays and a wide range of priorities, and balancing consistency of approach with flexibility to reflect different issues. Similarly, in places such as Indonesia, with thousands of islands and millions of people spread across thousands of kilometres of ocean space, MaPP can offer useful comparisons to support planning and stakeholder engagement. At the same time, it shows that high-quality ocean planning can occur and be successful while taking into account issues such as governance, Indigenous rights, jurisdiction and authority.

The MaPP partners believe this collaborative approach to planning in the North Pacific Coast has worked because of the enormous effort made by all parties to build trust, establish open lines of communication, address differences and conflicts, agree on deliverables and scope and make decisions together.

In short, good process has contributed to building relationships that will outlast the latest information, science or policy. Furthermore, the MaPP approach is a huge step towards achieving the B.C. government’s commitment to reconciliation with First Nations.

MaPP is a collaborative partnership between 17 member First Nations and the Province of British Columbia. MaPP plans and other information can be found at mappocean.org.


IN FOCUS: BUILDING A SUB-REGIONAL PLAN

Each of the four sub-regional plans developed had its own process, unique participants, stakeholders and objectives. The following are some highlights relating to the development of the sub-regional plans.

Pre-2011 Local First Nations complete individual community plans. Existing provincial plans, policies, legislation and management procedures.
November 2011 MaPP is formed. The local First Nation plans are used as the basis for development of preliminary draft plan components with the Province, which then augments with exiting provincial legislation, policies and management measures to be used in discussions with stakeholders.
Late fall 2011 through June 2014 To build the sub-regional plans, the Marine Plan Advisory Committees (MPAC) are formed and go on to meet nearly 15 times over a two-year period to review draft plan components. Supporting the process are two co-leads (one representing the First Nations and the other representing the Province) and a wealth of expertise from partner organizations staff.

MaPP partner technical staff work together to develop shared planning tools (zoning framework, recommended uses and activities table, vulnerability matrix, compatibility matrix, Sea Sketch online mapping, current conditions and trends reports, and a plan assessment process). The sub-regional planning teams use information from available or internal research, consultant reports and stakeholder input to build the overall plan.

Public open houses are held in sub-regional communities, launching a six-week public review period in the spring of 2014. Based on public input, proposed changes to the plan are subsequently reviewed and/or incorporated.

Among the topics discussed as part of the development of a sub-regional plan are: a vision statement; ecosystem-based management issues, objectives and strategies; climate change; tsunami debris management; marine pollution; marine conservation and protection; cultural and heritage resources; marine recreation and tourism; commercial, recreational and First Nations fisheries; the tenuring process; aquaculture; log handling and storage; energy; infrastructure; collaborative management and governance; monitoring and enforcement; marine research and education; communities and economy; and zoning framework.

April 2015 A signing ceremony is held at the B.C. Legislature in Victoria where sub-regional partner representatives, technical staff and stakeholders celebrate the signing of the four sub-regional marine plans.
May 2016 Regional Action Framework is signed.
August 2016 Four separate implementation agreements between the B.C. government and sub-regional First Nations are signed.

Contact person:

  • Josie Byington
  • Communications Assistant
  • Marine Plan Partnership
  • jbyington@mappocean.org 
  • 250-816-1934

mapp logo

By John Bones, Charles Short, Steve Diggon. The Marine Plan Partnership for the North Pacific Coast (MaPP) is a co-led process between 17 First Nations and the Government of the Province of British Columbia that developed and is implementing plans for marine uses on B.C.’s North Pacific Coast, now and into the future. The MaPP initiative is notable also for the diversity of stakeholders involved and the number of marine uses, activities and values addressed. For more information on Marine Plan Partnership for the North Pacific Coast (MaPP) visit http://mappocean.org/


Advertisements so SEVENSEAS Media can remain a free resource for you:




SEVENSEAS Media logo for marine conservation articles

Check out more of the the latest articles on SEVENSEAS Media here. You can take a break from your day and check out some art on the SEVENSEAS Media Gallery here. Want to get in touch with questions or a submission? Contact us here.

Conservation Photography

Finding Ourselves on the Edges: Three Years on a Global Expedition

Andi Cross reflects on three years, 47 countries, and 250 communities on the Edges of Earth expedition. Stories from conservation’s frontlines.

Meeting Marie

I’d never seen colors like it. Red, orange, and yellow coming together over water. Resting over the horizon with a calm and still cerulean ocean below. The air smelled like coconut, probably because that’s all we’d been eating for a week, and probably because coconuts can be found everywhere in Vanuatu. I sat on the shore with Marie, her hand in mine. Hers were large, strong. Callused from years of experience. My other hand traced patterns in the sand, as if I might never touch this exact place again. And the truth was, I probably wouldn’t. That’s the struggle with being on a multi-year expedition around the world: you have to get good at saying goodbye to the people and places you fall in love with.

We sat in silence for a while before Marie asked me to read her the story I’d written about my partner, Adam Moore, and I diving her Little Bay. No one had ever gone far enough past the wave break to see what was out there, and she wanted to know what we’d found. After all, she spent her entire life protecting this stretch of ocean without ever catching a glimpse beneath its surface. I suspected she didn’t know how to swim, as that was common for Indigenous women of the South Pacific islands.

Andi Cross meets Marie Rite on the shore of Little Bay in Espiritu Santo, Vanuatu, during the Edges of Earth expedition
Meeting Marie Rite in Vanuatu.

A sense of nerves washed over me. What if she didn’t like it? What if my descriptions didn’t land? These are the things that run through your mind when you step into different cultures, into alternate worlds. You’re always wondering when your welcome will run thin. I was hesitant to start, but I couldn’t deny the request. She had been so gracious hosting us for over a week, as if we were two of her own.

I cleared my throat, and with a shaking voice, began by describing the will power it took to get there in the first place. I had been the one to reach out to Marie wanting to learn more about the bay. I’d seen a single photo of it online in my research of the region, and in turn, found her—appearing as nothing more than an email address. I had no idea who she was or what she looked like. If she’d even respond at all to my random fascination with her home, in what some would call the middle of nowhere.

Coastal views of Little Bay on Espiritu Santo, Vanuatu
Scenes from Little Bay on the island of Espiritu Santo, Vanuatu.

Marie had to travel 45 minutes from her village in the north of Espiritu Santo down to the provincial capital, Luganville, to even begin our correspondence. Our conversations came in fragments, half-understood words. There was a significant amount of waiting between messages. But after a few months, we had somehow made a plan. She agreed to open up one of her bungalows to me, and I agreed to show up.

Our instant connection was uncanny, despite coming from completely different worlds. Me, a New Yorker who had moved to the other side of the globe to become a scuba diver. Her, a ni-Vanuatu from a nation comprising 83 islands. I found immediate comfort in her warm smile. In her welcoming gift of a road-side coconut. She hugged me so tightly upon our first meeting, as if we were kindred spirits.

Marie Rite’s handcrafted beachside bungalows for conservation-focused guests in Vanuatu
Marie’s hand-crafted bungalows that she now rents out to conservation-focused guests.

I went on to recount the small pranks she played on us throughout our stay. All our shared laughter. I told her how I felt more relaxed than I can remember sleeping in her handmade beachside bungalows—the sound of the ocean rocking me to sleep every night. How her cooking—from the coconut crab the size of my head to the fresh fish caught just down the road—would be forever embedded in our memories. I told her how both Adam and I valued every detail she so meticulously planned, all to ensure we felt like Vanuatu was a place we could call our own. Even if we all knew it never would be.

Looking back on that first plunge into Marie’s Little Bay, we were met with a reef untouched by time. Vibrant and alive, unlike anything we had seen. Colors that only nature can create, much like the Vanuatuan sunset, flooded our senses. It was hard not to get emotional. Adam and I had seen so much damage underwater—where even the most iconic reefs are struggling with bleaching, pollution, degradation. But this place was free from those scars. I was thankful to see something so wholesome and resilient could still be found in this hard world. Both on land and out to sea. The reef reminded me of Marie.

Shallow coral reef alive with marine life in Vanuatu’s Little Bay
The reefs of Vanuatu are shallow and alive with life.

I paused and looked over at her. She was crying, trying to hide away the tears rolling down her rounded face. “No one has ever written a story like this for me. I never knew what was in my Little Bay. Now you’ve shown me. My work protecting it was worth something. I’ll never forget you for this.”

For Marie, this newfound knowledge meant she had the ability to open her bungalows to divers. An alternate livelihood she, and her entire community, so desperately needed. The pandemic had hit Vanuatu’s tourism businesses hard, like it did throughout most of the Pacific Islands. She walked me through her grand plans. I had helped make them actionable and sustainable. And on my end, I was starting to realize Adam and I were on to something bigger with this expedition concept we’d conjured up. I’d envisioned a future where my calling was here, on the edges, helping people see what might be out of sight, even in their own backyard.

Underwater photograph of the Little Bay reef, shown to Marie Rite for the first time
One of the first photos we showed Marie of the Little Bay reef.

Discovering Our Edge

I met Marie in 2023, not fully understanding the gravity of that moment. I didn’t yet know that Adam and I would go on to meet many more people like her on what we had started calling the Edges of Earth expedition—an idea that first surfaced years earlier, in 2019. I didn’t know how many times we’d have to say goodbye. How often we’d leave places we had come to love.

It all started when I moved from the east coast of the United States to the far-flung remoteness of Western Australia. Perth, the only major city in the state, felt rugged in a way I couldn’t fathom coming from a city of nearly nine million. People went barefoot to the supermarket. Kangaroos were just as much neighbors as humans. Status wasn’t tied to what you earned, but instead to the size of the waves you could surf. At least, that’s how I came to understand it through Adam.

Andi Cross diving in Western Australia as a professional scuba diver sponsored by SSI and Scubapro
Author, Andi Cross, becoming a professional scuba diver, sponsored by SSI and Scubapro, while living in Western Australia.

The more we explored this wild west, the more a question began to follow me: what else is out there? In the vastness of a state the size of half the US, with only three million people spread across it, I tapped into an insatiable curiosity. One that came less from ambition, and more from a desire to understand what I did not.

At the time, Adam was working brutally long days as an accountant while I was in strategy, selling things that didn’t feel like they mattered, to people who didn’t really need them. We had built clear, defined skills over the course of our twenties. But the way we were using them didn’t sit right. Was this really it? Was this how we were meant to spend our lives? Slaves to a computer screen? Selling our souls to whatever mega company we were to work for next?

As our relationship grew, so did our time mulling over those questions. We’d brainstorm on long car rides looking for surf about the life we wanted. And about what we could actually contribute to the cause we both passionately cared about: Earth. As we contrasted our workdays with weekends spent on Western Australia’s white-sand beaches, we watched as two completely different versions of life were unfolding.

Aerial view of Western Australia’s coastline
Views of Western Australia from above.

At the same time, I was diving nonstop—what had brought me here in the first place. I was spending nearly as much time underwater as I was on land, documenting places like the Great Barrier Reef and the Coral Triangle whenever I could. And with every dive, I started to notice where there was beauty, there was also destruction. Plastic caught in coral and damage where there should have been life. Every dive reminded me of the tension my life now held. The endless consumer products of my origins and the wilderness of my new home.

I was living in two worlds that didn’t reconcile. New York was the place that shaped me—centered around consumption, ambition, and always-on speed. And then there was Perth—a place that stripped things back, reconnecting me to nature while pulling me further from everything familiar. I couldn’t fully belong to either. I felt stuck between them, trying to figure out how to make sense of both without turning my back on one.

Andi Cross diving the Ningaloo Reef near Exmouth in Western Australia
Author diving around Exmouth and the Ningaloo Reef, north of Perth, Western Australia.

My dive guides, often locals, would unknowingly cut through that internal battle. They spoke about their work with a kind of actualization I didn’t have. Their lives were centered around protecting their home. They were fixated on restoring reefs by hand, removing waste piece by piece, pushing for policies to safeguard what remained. Not for recognition and certainly not for reward. Just because it was theirs to protect. They were doing it out of love.

I was struck by these narratives. By how deeply they could commit to a place, while I still had a foot in two worlds. Of all the questions building in me about our planet in decline, my purpose, and where I fit into any of it, one rose above the rest. Why weren’t these stories from the edges being told?

Beach cleanup on Christmas Island, Australia, collecting plastic waste washed ashore
Conducting a beach cleanup on Christmas Island, Australia, that gets heavy waste washing up on its shores.

By 2023, Adam and I couldn’t ignore these questions anymore. We both wanted to feel something different in our work, and we wanted to understand how other people were building lives that felt aligned with what mattered to them. So we sold most of what we owned, cancelled our lease, and packed our lives into two bags. One for dive gear, the other for everything else.

The plan was to move from one edge to the next. Spend time with people doing the hardest work in the field. Instead of leading or talking, we were to listen and learn. And our hope was, with the skills and connections we had, we could help carry their impact further. A few people took a chance on us in those early days. Marie was one of them.

Local dive guides whose conservation stories inspired the Edges of Earth expedition
Meeting local dive guides and hearing their stories of conservation is what inspired the Edges of Earth expedition.

A New Way of Life

The rest of 2023 was spent moving through the South Pacific and Southeast Asia, each step across the eastern hemisphere testing us in ways we hadn’t anticipated. We learned quickly how to adapt—to unfamiliar food, to constant movement, to discomfort that slowly became routine. Nights on the floor of a makeshift cabin with Kanak families in the north of New Caledonia toughened us. A cliffside shelter in the Solomon Islands, with torrential rain hammering down for a week straight, showed us how little we actually needed. Sleepless nights camping in Thailand, sea lice lighting our skin on fire, made us appreciate our health in a way we never had before.

And it didn’t ease up. In Cambodia, relentless storms left us unsure what we’d wake up to. In Vietnam, pollution was inescapable—on land and underwater. The Andaman Islands brought food poisoning that stopped us in our tracks. In the Philippines, we came face-to-face with illegal fishing fleets that shook us to our core. It was physically draining in a way that could have broken us. But what hit us harder was the weight of what we were seeing.

Edges of Earth team living alongside the Kanak community in northern New Caledonia
Living alongside the Kanak in the north of New Caledonia.

It’s one thing to read about a changing climate. It’s another to live inside it. To see, up close, how the most vulnerable communities are carrying the consequences of decisions made far beyond their control. They would often be living among trash that has washed in from other countries that were far more populated than their slice of island. They would experience intensifying storms that would destroy their homes and deplete them of their savings. Large in part due to a warming planet that they had very little to do with based on their carbon footprint.

We’d lie awake at night, silent, trying to process it all. The damage and scale of it. The responsibility we started to realize was in our hands to ensure we weren’t extracting and giving as much as we could instead. By morning, we were exhausted—not just from the harsh conditions, but from our endless cognitive processing of what we had seen.

And still, we never questioned being there. Because every day, we were alongside people who refused to give up. We were diving, trekking, documenting alongside scientists, First Nations communities, conservationists, and activists. And over and over, there it was: that same connection I had felt with Marie. It didn’t matter where we came from or how different our lives looked. We were always welcomed with open arms when able to communicate our shared commitment to protect what was still here.

What was most potent, however, was the outlook of those we met. These were people living on the frontlines of the climate crisis, watching their ecosystems change in real time. Despite the drama of this loss, their stories weren’t well known; they weren’t social media stars and the contents of their days weren’t clickbait. And yet, their sense of purpose was unwavering. Instead of being stuck in place, paralyzed by what was happening to them, they were acting on it. It forced us to look at ourselves differently. When we showed up exhausted or overwhelmed, carrying the weight of the problem, while they carried only solutions, we had to check ourselves.

Meeting the Moken people in Thailand on the Edges of Earth expedition to learn about their seafaring culture
Meeting the Moken people in Thailand to learn about their culture.

Take the Tetepare Descendants Association of the Solomon Islands. They pushed to keep their ancestral homeland free from the logging industry—one of the only successful holdouts of 1,000 islands in the country to do so. Or Andaman Discoveries of Thailand, helping the once nomadic Moken people reclaim their seafaring ways after the government revoked them in 2004. Or Marine Conservation Cambodia, which was warding off illegal trawlers that were killing off the country’s marine life.

These people became our colleagues and our friends. Our guiding teachers and our definition of heroes. Because of this, our expedition work was far from some pursuit of discovery, or a claim to something new—which is how we once understood expeditioning to be. This instead was a journey to stand alongside those already doing the hardest work, and to help it reach beyond the edges they were fighting to protect.

Edges of Earth expedition teams and conservation partners in the field
The teams met in the field on expedition have become friends, and in some cases, family.

Finding the Positive Outliers

By 2024, we found ourselves driving the length of Central America in a car that was barely street legal, crossing rough borders from Panama to Belize. Along the eastern coast of Mexico, we dove the world’s deepest blue hole, spending time learning from the fishermen who had first discovered it on how they were now planning on protecting it. Further north, we dove through the cenotes—sacred sinkholes and caves that the Mayans called their underworld. We crossed the country to see how marine protected areas were being created and enforced by local communities, those deeply connected to this land so rich with biodiversity.

In South America, we moved through Patagonia and out to the Falkland Islands / Malvinas, where king penguins wandered close without hesitation. Off Argentina, elephant seals stretched across the shoreline, unfazed by our presence. It often felt like we had arrived at exactly the right moment for the perfect wild encounter. But for us it was never about that. We were always searching for the human connection.

Adam Moore, co-founder of Edges of Earth, diving Mexico’s cenotes
Adam Moore, Co-Founder of the Edges of Earth Consulting and Expedition team, diving Mexico’s cenotes.

By the time we reached the southernmost tip of the Americas, two years in, we had documented close to 200 of these progressive case studies. We called them this because, to us, they were blueprints for a better future—repeatable models that others could use, if experiencing similar challenges, in similar environments. Through this, we had met over 1,000 positive outliers, as we started to call them. People and teams facing their ecological and cultural challenges head on, and making a real difference despite the odds.

When we immersed ourselves in places far removed from what we once called “normal,” the more living at the edges began to change us. It was showing up in what we chose to eat, forcing us to reduce our meat and fish intake. It crept up in the conversations we were having, finding ourselves in heated conversations about the challenges of open-net salmon farming instead of what’s trending on Netflix. It even started showing up in how we looked, as we rotated through four outfits and washed our clothes in buckets. We didn’t care. We loved it.

Wildlife encounter on the Edges of Earth global expedition
There have been no shortages of incredible wildlife encounters on the edges.

In return, we leaned into our role on behalf of those on the edges. We were never in these places to lead conservation work, but rather, to help move it forward. To connect these teams with the exposure and support they needed—whether through funding, media, or simply getting the right people to pay attention. We had the ability to do that because of our previous corporate careers, which was largely why I didn’t want to turn my back on home. Home gave me something valuable—a tangible skill and the work ethic to back it up. It just had to be harnessed and curated in the right way. Towards something that provided value to people who needed it most. And because of that, the relationships we built didn’t end when we moved on. If anything, they deepened.

I remember a stretch of road through Patagonia on the Chilean side, asking Adam if we’d ever be able to live like we once did back in New York, or even Perth. Perth felt large now. Would we care about what we wore, what we owned, how big our house was? Could we go back to small talk about the weather? Would we always be thinking about the intensifying storms we’d seen on expedition instead? Could we eat the same processed foods, knowing the true cost with every bite?

Andi Cross and Adam Moore, co-founders of the Edges of Earth collective, after three years on expedition
Andi Cross and Adam Moore co-founded the Edges of Earth collective and have been on expedition for three years.

By the time we had crossed five countries in South America and were on our way to Africa, we had our answer. There was no “going back.” Even our physicality had changed—hardly recognizable to fair-weather-friends who knew us in another life. Our face and limbs were always lightly dusted with dirt. Hair knotted and sunbleached, from too much exposure to the elements. Our hands had hardened. They reminded me of Marie.

Our Future on the Edges

Today, we are three years into this global voyage. Six continents, 47 countries, 250 communities, and counting. We’re still meeting people on all kinds of edges, from the most remote to the most urban. Positive outliers exist everywhere, if you’re willing to look closely enough.

Scuba diving as a connector between the Edges of Earth team and remote communities
Diving has been the greatest connector, bringing us close to people we’d otherwise never meet on the edges.

We measure success differently now. In the relationships built and in the tears we shed upon a goodbye. When we get to share with a woman, for the first time, what sits beneath the surface of her Little Bay that she spent her life protecting. That’s success. Marie was the one who showed us what life on the edges could be. She reframed why we explore. While it was never about the perfect shot, or the dopamine hit of Instagram likes, we didn’t have a full handle on the “why.” She showed us that, to explore, means to forge deeper human connection. Exploration means helping people see what has always been there, even if just slightly out of reach.

What we didn’t expect was how hard it would be to carry that way of living back with us. To sit in a city and not think about the coastlines we’ve seen changing. To have conversations that skim the surface after years spent in places where everything discussed is painfully deep about our planet’s future. To exist within systems of overconsumption and resource extraction that we once moved through so easily, now seeing them for what they are. We’re still learning how to live with that tension. How to exist in both worlds without turning away from either. How to let them benefit one another, instead of letting the never-ending contradictions pull us to shreds.

Positive outliers met across the Edges of Earth expedition, from polar ice to tropical seas
From the ice to the tropics, we have met positive outliers in every place we’ve been fortunate enough to explore.

Escaping one life for another was never the grand plan. It was to understand how to bring them together. To take what we’ve learned on the edges—the way people commit themselves to something bigger than they are—and apply it to the lives we came from. To think more boldly and to question what we know. To act with intention, which we certainly didn’t fully grasp before this journey. Back then, we were more fixated on ourselves—what we needed and wanted—oblivious to the fact that even our smallest actions cause ripple effects reaching the ends of the Earth.

We’re not finished. There are still more positive outliers to meet and more case studies to carry forward. But our burning questions have changed. Gone are the days of chasing “what’s out there?” or “where do I fit in?” Those questions feel selfish now. Instead, we’re asking how far stories of human ingenuity can reach. Can they outshine the clickbait? Can they shift culture? Can they open our eyes to what we stand to lose if we don’t change our ways? We will keep showing up to play our part in it all. At home and on every edge that welcomes us next.


About the Cover Conservationists

Andi Cross, co-founder of Edges of Earth and SEVENSEAS Cover Conservationist, in scuba gear at the water's edge
Andi Cross, co-founder, Edges of Earth
Adam Moore, co-founder and photographer of Edges of Earth and SEVENSEAS Cover Conservationist, on a coastal expedition
Adam Moore, co-founder, Edges of Earth

Andi Cross and Adam Moore are the co-founders of Edges of Earth, a multi-year global expedition documenting the people, places, and practices shaping the future of ocean and land conservation. Three years in, they have traveled across six continents, 47 countries, and 250 communities, working alongside the scientists, First Nations leaders, conservationists, and local stewards they call positive outliers. Andi writes and leads the storytelling side of the expedition; Adam handles photography and field direction. Follow their journey at edgesofearth.com.

Continue Reading

Aquacultures & Fisheries

What the Fish Are Telling Us About Marine Biodiversity and Ocean Health Around Tenerife

Tenerife sits in the eastern Atlantic like a crossroads. Positioned roughly 300 kilometres off the northwest coast of Africa, the island intersects the paths of the Canary Current, warm subtropical surface waters, and the deep cold upwellings of the Atlantic basin. The result is one of the most ecologically productive marine environments in the northern hemisphere, a place where bluefin tuna from the Mediterranean share waters with tropical reef species and migratory whales from the polar ocean. What lives in these waters, and how those populations are changing, tells us something important about the health of the broader Atlantic system.

The Anatomy of an Exceptional Marine Environment

The waters around Tenerife support approximately 400 species of fish, a number that reflects the unusual convergence of marine provinces that the island straddles. [1] Its seafloor topography is dramatic: the island drops away steeply from the coast, reaching oceanic depths within just a few kilometres of shore. This proximity of shallow coastal habitat to very deep water creates conditions that support both reef-associated species and the large pelagic predators of the open ocean, sometimes within sight of the same beach.

In the deeper offshore waters, the Canary Islands are internationally recognised as one of the finest big game fishing destinations in the world, and for good reason. Atlantic bluefin tuna (Thunnus thynnus) pass through in their thousands between December and April, migrating northward toward Mediterranean spawning grounds. These are not small fish. Individuals regularly exceed 250 kilograms, and the largest bluefin recorded in these waters approach 450 kilograms. [2] Their spring passage coincides with dense schools of Atlantic mackerel (Scomber scombrus) and smaller baitfish that concentrate near the island, drawing the giants in from the open Atlantic.

Blue marlin (Makaira nigricans) and white marlin (Kajikia albida) are present from spring through autumn, the two billfish species that define Tenerife’s reputation among dedicated sport anglers. Spearfish (Tetrapturus belone) inhabit the deeper offshore trenches. Yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares), bigeye tuna (Thunnus obesus), wahoo (Acanthocybium solandri), and mahi-mahi (Coryphaena hippurus) complete a pelagic assemblage that few locations outside the tropics can match. [2]

Closer to shore, the volcanic reef structures support a different community. Atlantic amberjack (Seriola dumerili), barracuda (Sphyraena viridensis), grouper (Epinephelus spp.), and European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) inhabit the rocky substrates, alongside numerous wrasse species, bream, and moray eels. The deeper sandy bottoms, where slow-jigging techniques are most effective, hold species less visible to tourists but central to local gastronomy: red porgy (Pagrus pagrus), sargo (Diplodus sargus), and various sparids that have been fished by Canarian communities for centuries. [3]

Reading the Signals: What Is Changing

The richness of this marine environment is not static, and the signals coming from the water are mixed. On one hand, the resident cetacean populations tell a story of relative stability. Whale Watch Tenerife, which has logged cetacean sightings systematically since 2018, recorded 17 different species in both 2018 and 2023, with short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala macrorhynchus) and bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) present on nearly every survey day. [4] In 2025, orca sightings and encounters with fin whales were notable additions to the year’s record. [4] The continued presence of these apex predators is generally a positive indicator of ecosystem function.

On the other hand, the EU-funded OCEAN CITIZEN restoration project documented concerning trends at the base of the food web when it began its work on the island in 2024. Fish populations associated with rocky reef habitats have declined significantly compared to historical baselines. Seagrass meadows (Cymodocea nodosa), which serve as nurseries for juvenile fish and feeding grounds for sea turtles, have retreated across multiple coastal areas due to sedimentation, pollution, and rising water temperatures. Rocky reefs have been degraded by a combination of physical disturbance and the effects of ocean acidification. [5] These are not peripheral problems. Reef habitats and seagrass meadows are foundational to the productivity that ultimately supports the entire marine food web, from the smallest reef fish to the bluefin tuna and the pilot whales that hunt above them.

The Atlantic regulatory framework governing commercial fishing has also evolved. EU fisheries ministers, meeting in December 2025, set 2026 catch limits with 81 percent of total allowable catches in the northeast Atlantic at maximum sustainable yield levels — an improvement on previous years, though the failure to agree a mackerel quota for 2026 due to disputes with non-EU countries was a notable setback. [6] For sport and recreational fishing around Tenerife, a growing culture of catch and release has taken hold among charter operators, particularly for bluefin tuna, billfish, and other large pelagic species. Most reputable charters now apply mandatory release for bluefin tuna, reflecting both changing regulation and a shift in the values of visiting anglers. [3]

What the Fish Are Actually Telling Us

Marine ecosystems are exceptionally good at communicating ecological stress, if we know how to listen. The presence of 28 cetacean species, including year-round resident pilot whales, tells us that the deep-water food web west of Tenerife remains productive. The decline of reef fish populations and seagrass cover tells us that the shallower coastal zone is under sustained pressure from human activity. The continued migration of bluefin tuna past the island tells us that large-scale Atlantic management is beginning to take effect after decades of overfishing. The appearance of orcas and large baleen whales in 2025 tells us that the waters retain the biological richness to attract ocean wanderers from across the hemisphere.

Tenerife’s marine environment is neither pristine nor beyond recovery. It occupies a contested middle ground where genuinely exceptional natural heritage coexists with the pressures of one of Europe’s busiest tourist destinations. Paying attention to what lives here, in all its scientific specificity, is the first step toward deciding what kind of relationship the island will have with its sea.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Tenerife — fauna and marine ecology
  2. FishingBooker: Tenerife Fishing — The Complete Guide for 2026, fishingbooker.com, January 2026
  3. FishingBooker: Canary Islands Fishing — The Complete Guide for 2026, fishingbooker.com
  4. Whale Watch Tenerife: Tenerife Whale Watching Season — cetacean sighting data 2023-2025, whalewatchtenerife.org
  5. OceanCitizen EU: Reclaiming Tenerife’s Ocean, oceancitizen.eu, September 2024
  6. European Commission Oceans and Fisheries: Fisheries ministers agree fishing opportunities for 2026, December 2025, oceans-and-fisheries.ec.europa.eu
Continue Reading

Art & Culture

A Nature Traveller’s Guide to Tenerife (With a 7-Day Itinerary)

south coast does exactly what it promises. But Tenerife is an island of extraordinary geographical and ecological variety, and the version of it visible from a resort terrace is perhaps the least representative of what the island actually is.

Tenerife is home to Spain’s highest mountain, three distinct rural parks, a UNESCO biosphere reserve of ancient laurel forest, villages perched at elevations above 1,400 metres, volcanic landscapes that look like the surface of Mars, and a western coastline of sheer black cliffs falling 600 metres into the Atlantic. It has colonial cities with 16th-century architecture, cave-dwelling communities, stargazing sites that rival professional observatories, and natural tidal pools carved into lava rock where locals have swum for generations, completely uninterested in tourism. The island has a population of around 930,000 people living real, varied lives, and understanding a little of that life makes a visit significantly richer.

This guide is for travellers who want more of that Tenerife.

Understanding the Island’s Geography

Getting oriented matters here, because the island’s regions are genuinely distinct and travelling between them takes time. The central volcanic massif, dominated by Mount Teide at 3,715 metres, divides the island climatically: the north is wetter, cooler, and dramatically green; the south is dry, sunny, and more arid. The three main rural areas — Anaga in the northeast, Teno in the northwest, and the Teide highlands in the centre — each offer a completely different landscape and character. A rental car is essential for exploring any of them independently, and it is worth noting that many mountain roads are narrow, steep, and genuinely demanding to drive.

Where to Stay: Choosing Your Base

The most interesting places to base yourself are not on the resort strip. Here are four alternatives worth considering.

La Laguna (northeast) is a UNESCO World Heritage Site and one of the most beautiful colonial towns in the Atlantic islands. It was the original capital of Tenerife and its historic centre is a grid of 15th and 16th-century streets filled with carved wooden balconies, baroque churches, and a genuinely lively student population from the nearby university. Staying here puts you within easy reach of Anaga Rural Park and Santa Cruz, without sacrificing urban infrastructure. Hotel Laguna Nivaria, housed in a 16th-century mansion, is one of the finest small hotels on the island. 1

Garachico (northwest) was the most important port in the Canary Islands until the volcanic eruption of 1706 destroyed much of it and permanently altered the coastline. What remained was rebuilt thoughtfully, and today it is arguably the most architecturally coherent small town in Tenerife. The natural lava pools at El Caletón, formed in the same eruption that destroyed the port, are now a beloved public swimming area. Boutique Hotel San Roque, an 18th-century mansion facing the sea, and Hotel El Patio, a 16th-century farmhouse set in a 60-acre banana plantation, are both exceptional places to stay. 2

Vilaflor (central highlands) at 1,400 metres above sea level is the highest municipality in Spain, and sitting within it feels genuinely remote. Pine forest surrounds the village, the air smells of resin and altitude, and Teide National Park is just a short drive away. For travellers prioritising time in the volcano landscape, basing yourself here rather than driving up from the coast every day changes the experience entirely.

Anaga villages (northeast) — in particular Taganana, the oldest agricultural settlement in Tenerife, set in a steep valley running down to a black-sand beach — offer a different kind of immersion. Accommodation here is small-scale and basic, but the location inside the biosphere reserve, with walking trails directly from the door, is hard to match.

The Three Landscapes You Must Understand

Teide National Park and the Volcanic Interior

Teide is the obvious centrepiece, and it deserves its reputation. The national park is a UNESCO World Heritage Site and one of the most visited natural sites in the world, but it is large enough that you can find solitude if you walk beyond the car parks. The caldera, known as Las Cañadas, is a 17-kilometre wide depression formed by the collapse of a previous volcanic edifice, and the landscape within it — lava rivers, ash plains, volcanic cones in shades of ochre and rust, and the extraordinary Roques de García rock formation — is unlike anything else in Europe. 3

The summit of Teide itself requires a permit to access the final 200 metres to the crater rim; permits are free but must be reserved well in advance through the national park website. The Telesforo Bravo trail, when an entry permit is obtained, is one of the most extraordinary hikes on the island, ascending through multiple volcanic zones. For those without a summit permit, the trail around Roques de García is an accessible and genuinely beautiful alternative, taking roughly ninety minutes and offering Teide in full view throughout.

After sunset, the altitude and absence of light pollution make Teide one of the finest stargazing locations in the northern hemisphere. The Mirador de Llano de Ucanca and the Portillo area are good spots for amateur stargazing; guided telescope tours depart from various operators in the park. 4

Anaga Rural Park: The Ancient Forest

Anaga is, in a very literal sense, one of the oldest living things in Europe. The laurisilva — the laurel forest — that covers much of this UNESCO biosphere reserve is a relic of the subtropical forests that covered much of southern Europe and North Africa before the Pleistocene ice ages. When those forests vanished from the continent, pockets survived in the Canary Islands, Madeira, and the Azores. Walking through Anaga’s mist-covered ridges and moss-draped trees is not merely walking through an old forest; it is walking through a landscape that has not fundamentally changed in millions of years. 5

The trails here range from gentle ridgeline walks with Atlantic views in both directions to more demanding descents into the deep barrancos (ravines) that separate the Anaga massif’s many ridges. The trail from Punta de Hidalgo up to the cave village of Chinamada — where several families still live in traditional cave houses carved into the hillside, some of them inhabited for centuries — is one of the most culturally and scenically rewarding hikes on the island. The coastal walk from the hamlet of Benijo to the Faro de Anaga lighthouse and back through Chamorga is longer and more demanding but offers one of the most remote feelings achievable in Tenerife. 6

The Cruz del Carmen visitor centre, at the main road through the park, is a useful orientation point and has staff who can advise on trail conditions.

The Teno Massif: Cliffs, Gorges, and Masca

The Teno Rural Park in the island’s northwest corner is geologically the oldest part of Tenerife, and it looks it — angular, layered, deeply eroded by millennia of wind and rain. The main road through the Teno mountains to the village of Masca is one of the most dramatic drives in Spain: a single-lane road that clings to cliffsides above thousand-metre drops, with a viewpoint that looks out across the Atlantic toward La Gomera.

Masca itself is a small village of stone houses that seems to cling to the mountainside by force of will. It has become increasingly popular in recent years, and an early start is strongly recommended to avoid the worst of the crowds. From Masca, the descent into the Barranco de Masca gorge to the black-sand beach at its base is one of the island’s iconic hikes, though it requires an advance permit and careful planning; boat collection from the beach rather than the return ascent is the standard approach. 7

Elsewhere in the Teno, the Chinyero Special Nature Reserve protects the site of the last volcanic eruption on Tenerife, which took place in 1909. The lava fields here are still raw and largely unvegetated, and the circular trail around the Chinyero cone gives a visceral sense of the island’s ongoing geological life. 8

Cultural Touchstones

Outside of nature, several experiences offer genuine insight into Canarian culture. La Laguna’s historic centre merits at least half a day of unhurried walking — the cathedral, the convents, the narrow streets of the Casco Histórico, and the Aguere cultural space. La Orotava, a town in the Orotava Valley on the northern slope of Teide, has some of the finest examples of traditional Canarian architecture anywhere in the islands: carved pine balconies, stone mansions, cobbled streets. The Casa de los Balcones is the most visited building in the town, though the whole historic centre is worth wandering. The valley below, filled with banana and potato terraces and still farmed in traditional strips, is a reminder that Tenerife had a complex agricultural life before tourism arrived.

The Drago Milenario in Icod de los Vinos — a Dracaena draco, or dragon tree, estimated to be between 500 and 1,000 years old — is one of the botanical landmarks of the Atlantic islands. The species is endemic to the Canary Islands and Madeira and was sacred to the indigenous Guanche people; its red sap was known as dragon’s blood and had ceremonial and medicinal uses. The tree in Icod is the largest specimen known. 9

For an encounter with the island’s pre-Hispanic past, the Pyramids of Güímar in the east of the island are a genuinely puzzling site: six stepped pyramidal structures of uncertain origin, oriented to the solstice sun. They were brought to international attention by the explorer Thor Heyerdahl, who believed them to be of pre-Columbian significance. The on-site museum presents multiple interpretive perspectives with appropriate caution.


Suggested 7-Day Itinerary

This itinerary is designed to move through the island’s distinct regions at a pace that allows genuine engagement with each. A rental car is essential throughout.

Day 1 — Arrive, La Laguna Check in to La Laguna. Spend the afternoon walking the historic centre. Evening in the city’s restaurant and bar scene.

Day 2 — Anaga Rural Park Full day in Anaga. Morning: drive the Anaga mountain road with stops at viewpoints above Taganana and the Cruz del Carmen visitor centre. Afternoon: hike the Punta de Hidalgo to Chinamada trail (roughly 4 hours round trip, moderate difficulty). Return to La Laguna.

Day 3 — Santa Cruz, then drive north to Garachico Morning in Santa Cruz: the Tenerife Auditorium, the Mercado Nuestra Señora de África, and the seafront. Early afternoon: drive to Garachico (roughly 1 hour). Check in. Explore the town and swim at El Caletón tidal pools before sunset.

Day 4 — Teno Massif and Masca Early start. Drive the Teno road to Masca (arrive before 9am). Walk the Barranco de Masca if booked in advance, exiting by boat; otherwise explore the village and hike the Santiago del Teide to Masca ridge trail. Afternoon: Chinyero lava field walk.

Day 5 — Drive south via La Orotava, ascend to Vilaflor Morning in La Orotava: Casa de los Balcones, the old town, the valley viewpoints. Drive through Icod de los Vinos to see the Drago Milenario. Continue south and upward to Vilaflor. Check in to local accommodation. Evening: early night ahead of Teide day.

Day 6 — Teide National Park Full day in the park. Morning: Roques de García circuit (1.5 hours). If summit permit held: Telesforo Bravo ascent. Afternoon: explore the caldera floor. Stay until after dark for stargazing at Mirador de Llano de Ucanca.

Day 7 — Anaga coast or rest day, return Optional: drive to Taganana for a walk down to the beach, or return to La Laguna for a last morning in the city. Depart.

Sources

  1. The Hotel Guru: Best Places to Stay in Tenerife, thehotelguru.com; Hotel Laguna Nivaria listing
  2. Secret Places: Boutique Hotels Garachico, secretplaces.com; Hotel El Patio and Boutique Hotel San Roque
  3. Our Wanders: Best Day Hikes in Tenerife, ourwanders.com, March 2026
  4. Tenerife Excursions: Tenerife — stunning nature between Teide, Anaga, and unique landscapes, escursionitenerife.com, October 2025
  5. Hiking Fex: Tenerife Hiking — 30 most beautiful hikes, hikingfex.com, September 2025
  6. Moon Honey Travel: Hiking Tenerife Mountains, moonhoneytravel.com
  7. Charlies Wanderings: The 7 Very Best Hikes in Tenerife, charlieswanderings.com, August 2025
  8. Our Wanders: Best Day Hikes in Tenerife — Chinyero section, ourwanders.com
  9. Let Y Go: Itinerary of the 6 Little-Known Villages of Tenerife — Icod de los Vinos section, letygoeson.it, July 2025
Continue Reading

Trending