Connect with us

Independent ocean journalism

runs on its readers.

Donate

Science & Research

Gallifrey Foundation and 12 Field Conservationists Launch a Free Online Shark Conservation Toolkit

Science & Research · Shark Conservation

Gallifrey Foundation and 12 Field Conservationists Launch a Free Online Shark Conservation Toolkit

The Shark Conservation Toolkit gathers 82 strategies from people working at landing sites and on boats in Kenya, Brazil, Pakistan, the Maldives and beyond, each rated for impact by the working group that wrote them. It is free, open to new entries, and unusually frank about what has failed.

By SEVENSEAS Media | Ocean Conservation

Split view at the waterline: a whale shark's spotted back fills the water below while five men stand on a wooden outrigger fishing platform above, against a cloudy sunset sky.
Fishermen and a whale shark share the water beside a fishing platform in remote Indonesia. Photo: Jono Allen / Kogia

One entry in the new Shark Conservation Toolkit tells its story in a single line. A fisher agreed to release sharks alive, and an ecotourism programme was developed to work with him in place of shark fishing. The note sits under the heading “Communities are open to change” with an impact score of 8 out of 10, next to suggestions to hold stakeholder workshops and to explain why sharks matter through radio, WhatsApp, posters and school theatre.

The toolkit was formally launched on 1 October in Geneva by the Gallifrey Foundation, a Geneva-based marine conservation nonprofit, together with 12 leaders of grassroots organisations. It is a free website, sharktoolkit.org, available in English, Spanish, French, Indonesian, Italian and Portuguese, with a PDF export for teams working offline or on slow connections. The launch press release announced 80 strategies. When SEVENSEAS checked the site on 11 November there were 82: 19 threats, 15 successes, 25 opportunities and 23 failures, spread across 19 themes ranging from fisheries and trade pressure to funding and project design flaws.

Why it was built

The press release describes a familiar problem. Short of money, separated by language and culture and sometimes by national policy, small conservation groups repeat projects that already exist elsewhere without knowing whether those projects worked. Antoinette Vermilye, co-founder of the Gallifrey Foundation, who led the effort, sets the toolkit against the fin trade: “As the global shark fin trade pushes two-thirds of species toward extinction, we coordinated a group of front line shark conservationists to build this toolkit.”

That figure needs a qualifier. It traces to a 2022 study in Conservation Letters led by Diego Cardeñosa, which DNA-tested fin trimmings sold in Hong Kong between 2014 and 2018. Of the 86 species identified, 61 are threatened with extinction. The finding is that most species in the fin trade are threatened, which is serious enough, not that the trade alone is pushing two-thirds of all sharks toward extinction. Across every shark, ray and chimaera, the 2021 global reassessment led by Nicholas Dulvy found 32.6% of assessed species threatened, rising to an estimated 37.5% once data-deficient species are counted at the same rate, with overfishing a threat to every one of the threatened species.

What the toolkit contains

Each strategy is a short card with a title, a category, a theme, a score from 0 to 10 and a handful of practical steps. Many read like notes taken during a workshop, which is roughly what they are. The highest-scoring success, at 10, is working with local heroes: teachers, divers, elders, fishers and the women who sell fish, given radio spots, posters or public awards, and then taken out to sea to see sharks for themselves.

The threat cards are the most specific. Against corruption, scored 9, the toolkit proposes a one-page integrity pact between the fisheries office, the local co-management committee and a neutral civil society group, a monthly public list of permits, fines and seized gear, and patrol crews assigned by lottery. Against weak enforcement, it suggests a six-page bylaw with a ladder of sanctions and six to ten paid part-time guardians recruited from former fishers. For groups that cannot cover running costs, it describes a local shark fund held in an account needing three signatures, with at least 60% of spending reserved for fuel, guardians and a data clerk.

Dead sharks laid out on wet grey sand, several hammerheads piled together and two grey sharks in the foreground, beside the legs and shadow of a standing person.
Sharks landed during shark fishing and finning in Zalala, Mozambique. Photo: Nessim Stevenson / Kogia

The failure category is what sets the toolkit apart from a list of good intentions. Contributors list short funding cycles (scored 9), laws introduced without giving communities the means to comply, a lack of genuine inclusion, and what one card calls “colonial structures in org, science and policy”. The remedies under that last heading include making local partners co-leads with at least 40% of the budget, and paying community knowledge holders as consultants rather than treating them as volunteers.

The strongest strategies in this toolkit came from people working at landing sites and on boats. It is built to keep growing, and it needs more frontline voices to do that.

Kira Evans, marine biologist, The Sharkline, Kenya

Sylvester Menza, a field officer with The Sharkline, puts it in similar terms. “Fishers and coastal teams know what protects sharks in practice,” he said. “This toolkit puts that knowledge in one place, so we can learn from each other across countries.”

A man in a black long-sleeved top and mirrored sunglasses stands on a beach with one arm raised, releasing a small quadcopter drone into a clear blue sky.
Sylvester Menza, field officer with The Sharkline, launches a drone from the beach.

Tourism appears on both sides of the ledger. As an opportunity, scored 7, the toolkit suggests a do-no-harm code for operators, with no baiting or chasing, alongside training for guides and 2 to 5% of revenue paid into a village fund. As a threat, under “unregulated tourism”, the toolkit proposes municipal licences that require distance rules, a cap on boats and mooring-only access, with 10 to 20% of each licence fee earmarked for a local shark fund. A separate threat, scored 1, is tourism pushing fishers out of their own waters, answered by reserving guide and boat crew places for trained fishers and setting up a fishers’ tourism cooperative.

Seen from below in hazy blue water, a whale shark swims downward with its tail curved, while snorkellers in fins kick at the bright surface above.
A whale shark and tourists in Pintuyan, Southern Leyte, Philippines. Photo: Zoe Lower / Kogia

How the scores work, and what they do not show

According to the toolkit’s methodology page, the material came from an in-person workshop with the 12 contributors. Their experiences were sorted into successes, failures, opportunities and threats, and any action mentioned seven or more times became a priority theme. Each action was then classed as easy to implement, needing further development, or not yet feasible, and tagged as working at local, national or beyond-national level.

The scores are a separate matter. The site describes them as fixed ratings of relative impact made by an international working group of practitioners, and comments from users do not change them. The methodology does not explain what separates a 4 from an 8, who scored which card, or what evidence sat behind each number, so the scores are best read as the judgement of experienced people rather than measured outcomes. A few cards also need editing. One success card says a reef shark can generate more than $250,000 in tourism revenue over its lifetime against $50 to $200 if killed, with no source given. A card titled “Shark squalene” has no content and a score of 0.

The press release calls the toolkit “first-of-its-kind”, which also deserves a footnote. Shark toolkits already exist: WWF and James Cook University released a Rapid Assessment Toolkit for Sharks and Rays in 2019, aimed at countries short of species data. That one is about collecting data. The Gallifrey toolkit is about tactics, failures included, and is designed to take submissions. Every card carries an “I tried this” button that records whether the approach worked, partly worked or did not, and users can propose new strategies, which the site says it reviews weekly and later monthly.

The research behind the numbers

Four peer-reviewed findings on shark and ray decline

A large school of hammerhead sharks swims through deep blue water among hundreds of small fish, lit from the surface above.
Hammerhead sharks in the Galápagos Islands. Photo: Sumer Verma / Kogia

Who built it

The 12 contributors are Ana Lucia Furtado Soares of the Angola Elasmo Project, Nathalie Gil of Sea Shepherd Brasil, Joshua Rambahiniarison of CORDIO East Africa in the Comoros, Randall Arauz of CREMA in Costa Rica, Armelle Jung of Des Requins et Des Humains in France, Nisha Ichida of ReShark in Indonesia, Abigail Kidd of The Sharkline in Kenya, Stella Diamant of the Madagascar Whale Shark Project, Arzucan “Zuzu” Askin of Miyaru in the Maldives, Shabib Asghar of Marine Conservation Pakistan, Callie Veelenturf of The Leatherback Project in Panama, and Ghofrane Labyedh, an independent marine biologist working in West Africa.

Underwater, a scuba diver in a blue rash guard holds a young striped and spotted zebra shark gently in both hands beneath the hull of a boat.
Zebra shark conservation work in Misool, Indonesia. Photo: Adam Moore / Kogia

Their organisations range from national branches of large networks to projects run by a handful of people, and the quotes in the launch material keep returning to the same idea. “None of us works alone,” said Abigail Kidd, founder of The Sharkline. Nathalie Gil of Sea Shepherd Brasil described working alone in shark conservation as very lonely, and said the toolkit means new groups do not have to start from scratch. Armelle Jung, head of science projects at Des Requins et Des Humains, said the aim is to protect both shark and human populations, and invited other practitioners to add their own experience so the tool becomes more effective.

Whether that happens depends on people outside the original 12 using the “I tried this” button and submitting their own cards, including the ones that did not work. With 82 entries and fixed scores, the toolkit is at present a well-organised record of one workshop. The submissions and outcome reports are what would turn it into the shared evidence base its contributors describe.

The Shark Conservation Toolkit is free at sharktoolkit.org, with its methodology and contributor list published alongside.

SEVENSEAS Media · Conservation Journalism for the Ocean

Subscribe for free

Join 50,000+ weekly subscribers.
Two separate newsletters, so take one or both. Compare the two

Building conservation careers since 2004

Free for everyone, funded by readers who can give.
Tax-deductible