Issue 95 - April 2023

Northern & Southern Resident Orcas Hunt Differently, Which May Help Explain The Decline of Southern Orcas

By Dr. Jennifer Tennessen,
a Senior Research Scientist at the Center for Ecosystem Sentinels,
in the Biology Department at the University of Washington

a killer whale swim out of the oean surface. — A southern resident orca in 2010. Credit: NOAA

In the Pacific Northwest and British Columbia, scientists have been sounding the alarm about the plight of southern resident orcas. Annual counts show that population numbers, already precarious, have fallen back to mid-1970s levels. Most pregnancies end in miscarriage or death of the newborn. They may not be catching enough food. And many elderly orcas — particularly post-reproductive matriarchs, who are a source of knowledge and help younger generations — have died.

With just 73 individuals left, conservationists and members of the public alike are concerned that southern resident orcas may not survive.

Yet over the same period, the region’s northern resident orcas, who have a similar diet and an overlapping territory, grew steadily in population. Today, there are more than 300 northern resident orcas, leaving scientists wondering why these two similar but distinct populations have had such dissimilar fates over the past half-century.

A new study led by scientists at the University of Washington and NOAA Fisheries reveals that the two populations differ in how they hunt for salmon, their primary and preferred food source. The research, done by an international team of government, academic and nonprofit researchers, was published on March 4 in Behavioral Ecology.

“For northern resident orcas, females were hunting and capturing more prey than males. For southern resident orcas, we found the opposite: The males were doing more hunting and capturing than females,” said lead author Jennifer Tennessen, a senior research scientist at the University of Washington’s Center for Ecosystem Sentinels. “We also found that if their mother was alive, northern resident adult males hunted less, which is consistent with previous work, but we were surprised to see that southern resident adult males hunted more. Adult females in both populations hunted less if they had a calf, but the effect was strongest for southern residents.”

The study’s five years of observational data show that southern resident males catch 152% more salmon per hour than females. In other words, for every two fish a southern female caught, a southern male would catch five. For the growing northern resident population, the trend is flipped: females caught 55% more salmon per hour than males.

A southern resident orca preying on salmon in the Salish Sea near Seattle. Credit: Su Kim/NOAA Fisheries

This is the first study to track the underwater pursuit, hunting and prey-sharing behaviors of both northern and southern resident orcas. Their findings reveal that, though the two populations overlap significantly in territory and have similar social structures and reproductive behavior, they should not be treated identically for conservation purposes.

“In the past, we’ve made assumptions about these populations and filled in the gaps when designing interventions, particularly to help the southern resident orcas,” said Tennessen, who conducted this study while she was a research scientist with NOAA’s Northwest Fisheries Science Center. “But what we found here are strikingly different patterns of behavior with something as critical to survival as foraging. And as we develop management strategies, we really need to consider these populations differently.”

NOAA scientists and an international team of collaborators temporarily tracked the movement, sounds, depth and feeding behaviors of 34 northern and 23 southern resident adult orcas non-invasively from 2009 to 2014 using “Dtags,” cellphone-sized digital devices. Dtags attach via suction to the back of an orca and, for this study, were programmed to fall off hours later and float back to the surface so the researchers could collect them and download their data.

As the name would suggest, northern resident orcas have a more northerly distribution, preferring waters around Vancouver Island and Queen Charlotte Strait. In contrast, core areas for southern resident orcas hug the southern reaches of Vancouver Island, inland waters surrounding the San Juan Islands, Puget Sound and the Washington coast. Both populations were devastated by the capture of orcas for theme parks, a practice that ended in the 1970s. Since then, northern resident orcas have increased steadily, seeing at least 50% growth since 2001.

Both populations hunt for salmon using echolocation. Adult orcas can dive at least 350 meters — or 1,150 feet — to pursue fish on their own, though they often bring kills to the surface to share with others. Pods travel between the outflows of major rivers and streams in British Columbia and Washington and have been heavily impacted by dams that have reduced salmon runs. Increased vessel traffic and noise in the Salish Sea — from tourism, recreation and shipping — have also negatively affected these populations, particularly the southern resident orcas, according to Tennessen.

A southern resident orca calf and its mother in 2004. Credit: NOAA National Ocean Service

This new study showed that southern residents had fewer successful hunts overall, indicating that they were presumably catching less food. This impact is particularly evident with young mothers.

“In both populations, a mother with a young calf foraged less than other females, possibly due to the risk of leaving the calf temporarily with ‘a babysitter’ — another adult — while she hunts, or because of the time demands of nursing a calf,” said Tennessen. “But for southern resident females, which are more prone to disturbance and stress from vessel traffic, there was an outsized effect: Our study found no instance of a southern resident female with a young calf who successfully carried out a hunt.”

The study also has much to say about the impact of elderly female orcas on their adult sons. Both northern and southern resident orcas are grouped into matriarchal clans, often led by post-reproductive females. They also help feed their adult sons even, as a recent study led by the nonprofit Center for Whale Research showed, at the expense of their own reproductive capacity.

The new study adds complexity to the role of elderly females. Among northern resident orcas, adult males with a living mother hunted less than adult males without a living mother, perhaps because the mother still provides food. But among southern resident orcas, the opposite is true: Adult males with a living mother hunted more.

“These unexpected differences left us scratching our heads. It is possible that southern resident adult males could be sharing with other members of their group, including their mothers, to help out, especially since an adult male’s survival is strongly linked to his mother’s survival,” said Tennessen. “Relatedly, southern resident matriarchs may be leading the group to areas where their adult sons may be able to capture more prey, since healthier sons might be more successful at mating and passing along some of their mothers’ genes. We need more studies to determine what role the presence — or absence, for southern resident orcas — of matriarchs has on male foraging behavior.”

Future studies on the behaviors of northern and southern resident orcas could bring these differences to the surface, as could studies of Alaska resident orca populations, which forage for salmon farther north, where salmon stocks are generally healthier. Such comparative studies can help isolate cause and effect, said Tennessen.

“Understanding how healthy populations behave can provide direction and goals for the management of unhealthy populations,” said Tennessen. “Future comparisons to healthy fish-eating orca populations could help us understand whether the divergent behavior we’re seeing in the southern residents is indicative of a population trying to survive.”

Co-authors on the paper are Maria Holt, Bradley Hanson and Candice Emmons with the NOAA Northwest Fisheries Science Center; Brianna Wright and Sheila Thornton with Fisheries and Oceans Canada; Deborah Giles with the UW Friday Harbor Labs; Jeffrey Hogan with the Cascadia Research Collective; and Volker Deecke with the University of Cumbria in the U.K. The research was funded by NOAA, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, the University of Cumbria and the University of British Columbia.

A NOAA scientist observing southern resident orcas from a research boat. Credit: Northwest Fisheries Science Center/NOAA Fisheries

About The University of Washington

Since its foundation in 1861, the University of Washington has been a hub for learning, innovation, problem-solving and community building. Driven by a mission to serve the greater good, our students, faculty, and staff tackle today’s most pressing challenges with courage and creativity, making a difference across Washington state — and around the world. Please visit for more info https://www.washington.edu.

[xyz-ihs snippet=”Prepared-by-PK”]

Up Next

SEVENSEAS Media is Working on Coral Restoration in Krabi, Thailand to Protect Marine Ecosystems

Don't Miss

Schmidt Ocean Institute Launches New Research Vessel That Will Change The Face of Ocean Exploration

Feature Destination

SEVENSEAS Travel Magazine – April 2023 – Issue 95

Feature Destination

Discover the Charm of Prince Edward Island: Your Ultimate Destination for Adventure and Relaxation

Prince Edward Island is one of Canada’s smallest provinces, situated on the country’s eastern coast. Despite its small size, this island is an incredibly charming and beautiful destination that offers visitors a unique experience. From its stunning beaches and picturesque countryside to its rich history and culture, Prince Edward Island is an excellent choice for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of modern life. Read more…

The Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons

The waters off the coast of Nova Scotia are rich in marine life, making them a popular destination for commercial fishing. However, concerns over the sustainability of these fishing practices have led to the establishment of a marine refuge in the Eastern Canyons region. Read more…

Five New Reasons to Visit New Brunswick, Canada This Summer

Areal shot of coves in New Brunswick Canada

Known for its vast untouched wilderness and more than 3,000 miles of coastline, New Brunswick, Canada is filled with adventures around every corner. Located just over the Maine border, the Atlantic Canada province offers a convenient destination for travellers looking to get off the beaten path. Read more…

Feature Destination: Ocean Conservation in Nova Scotia

SEVENSEAS’s March 2023 Beach Clean Up at Pan Beach in Krabi, Thailand

On March 25, 2023, we hosted our monthly beach clean up, and it was a success with the participation of 14 volunteers. The group covered up to a 400m stretch of beach, and they were able to pick up 60kg of trash from the beach. Most of the waste collected during the event were food wrappers and small plastic bits that were mixed with the sand and hidden in the vegetation, which made the cleaning process slow and tedious. See more…

SEVENSEAS Media is Working on Coral Restoration in Krabi, Thailand to Protect Marine Ecosystems

SEVENSEAS Media is excited to announce our latest conservation event in Krabi, Thailand – the coral restoration. As an online publication that strives to inspire conservation through education and engagement, we are committed to doing our part in protecting our planet’s ecosystems. With coral reefs under increasing threat from human activity and climate change, we feel it is more important than ever to take action to preserve these vital marine ecosystems. Read more…

NEWSROOM

Northern & Southern Resident Orcas Hunt Differently, Which May Help Explain The Decline of Southern Orcas

2023 Event Planning Toolkit & Action Focus for World Ocean Day

World Ocean Day provides a unique opportunity for a wide array of organizations, schools, businesses, and communities to honour and celebrate the ocean that connects us all! By uniting together, and with a special emphasis on engaging and connecting youth. Read more…

Endangered Baby Turtle & Juvenile Bamboo Shark Release at Anantara Phuket Resorts

Hawks-bill,Sea,Turtle,Release,To,The,Freedom

Anantara Layan Phuket Resort and Anantara Mai Khao Phuket Villas will celebrate this Thai New Year by releasing young turtles and juvenile bamboo sharks back into the ocean on April 13th & 14th. Anantara’s serene Layan and Mai Khao Phuket beaches offer secluded stretches of sand and sea. Read more…

New England Aquarium & Boston Harbor City Cruises to Offer New Ecoventure Cruise Experience

Boston Harbor City Cruises (BHCC), in partnership with the New England Aquarium, will offer a new cruise—the New England Aquarium Ecoventure Cruise—providing guests an up-close experience with marine life while protecting the whales who call these waters home. Read more…

A Global Resource: The Whale Watching Handbook

The whale-watching industry, regulators, policymakers and the general public can all benefit from the Whale Watching Handbook, a website dedicated to sustainable and educational whale watching. Read more…

Marine Heatwaves Decimate Sea Urchins, Molluscs & More at Rottnest

Tonga is a unique destination because it serves as the mating and calving grounds for endangered humpback whales. Every year, from July through November, the whales migrate from their feeding grounds in Antarctica to Tonga’s calm, tropical waters to give birth to their calves and mate. Read more…

Rebalancing Bermuda’s Ecosystem A Solution for Carbon Sequestration and Biodiversity Conservation

Seagrass ecosystems can sequester significant amounts of carbon and store it as organic carbon in sedim4ent for long periods, making them one of the most significant natural carbon sinks globally. They account for a minimal proportion of the world’s oceans at less than 0.2%. Read more…

Making The Case for Public Health Storytelling in Global Ocean Conservation

A recent literature review published in the journal Frontiers in Public Health makes a case for the use of public health framing to communicate issues facing marine and coastal ecosystems and inspire action from human communities all over the world to achieve the outcomes defined as part of the UN’s Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development. Read more…

Tech Startup, Hohonu, Raises $1.8M to Better Respond & Adapt to Flooding & Climate Change on Global Scale

Hohonu, an award-winning Hawaiʻi-based climate tech startup, announced it has completed a $1.8 million pre-seed funding round to scale its efforts to provide actionable data and insights to mitigate coastal flooding both nationally and internationally including Asia and the Pacific. Read more…

Schmidt Ocean Institute Launches New Research Vessel That Will Change The Face of Ocean Exploration

San Juan, Puerto Rico – Schmidt Ocean Institute launched today its newly refitted 110-meter global-class research vessel for use by scientists worldwide to dramatically advance marine science and push the frontiers of deep-sea expeditions. Read more…

Climate Change Could Cause Mass Exodus of Tropical Plankton

The tropical oceans are home to the most diverse plankton populations on Earth, where they form the base of marine food chains. Modern plankton biodiversity in the tropics is a surprisingly recent development and the result of 8 million years of global cooling, according to a study led by researchers at The University of Texas at Austin. Read more…

New Research Paper Reveals There’re More Than 170 Trillion Pieces of Platic Afloat in The World’s Oceans

A research paper published today in PLOS ONE reveals there are more than 170 trillion plastic particles, weighing approximately 2 million tonnes, afloat in the world’s oceans. By evaluating trends of ocean plastic from 1979 to 2019. Read more…

SEVENSEAS Beach Cleanup & Coral Restoration Events in Marine Protected Areas

In August 2022 CleanUp, we picked up over 80 kilograms of plastic, pieces of glasses, tractor tyres, and fishing nets from the beach in Krabi, Long Beach or Pan Beach. Of course, we would not be able to do it without your support. You can make a tax-deductible donation here to keep our publications and Thailand Cleanup Project afloat.

You can either make a direct financial contribution to SEVENSEAS Media through The Ocean Foundation website or connect us with potential donors by sending an email to Giacomo Abrusci, our Editor-in-Chief.

The FREE Weekly Conservation Post and Jobs List

Signing up for the free Weekly Newsletter & Jobs List will get you a round-up of upcoming events, webinars, meetings, reports, funding opportunities, photos of the week, and recent postings to the jobs list.

To sign up for our free subscription, please Click Here or email us Here.

Since 2004, SEVENSEAS Media has fostered an informal and non-partisan platform to promote understanding of key issues and challenges while building partnerships across an increasingly diverse group of marine conservation professionals and students.

Our mission is to promote communication and build partnerships across the global marine community and to identify and address gaps in the community’s work. SEVENSEAS Media achieves this through multimedia promotion and partnerships. The community consists of a diverse and growing group of participants, including non-governmental organizations, government agencies, foundations, bilateral and multilateral agencies, fellowship programs, independent consultants, and academia/students.

If you are interested in contributing or getting involved, email us Here.

[xyz-ihs snippet=”Prepared-by-PK”]

Feature Destination

Feature Destination: The Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons

The Eastern Canyons region is an area of deep-sea canyons and underwater mountains that are home to a variety of unique and endangered species. The area is also an important feeding ground for endangered North Atlantic right whales, which have been declining in number in recent years. The establishment of the marine refuge is aimed at protecting these important marine ecosystems and ensuring the sustainability of the fisheries that rely on them.

The decision to create the Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons was made after years of consultation with stakeholders, including fishermen, Indigenous communities, environmental organizations, and scientists. The process was led by Fisheries and Oceans Canada, which is responsible for managing Canada’s fisheries and protecting its oceans.

The marine refuge will be divided into two zones: a “core protection zone” and a “buffer zone.” The core protection zone will cover the canyons themselves and will be completely off limits to all commercial and recreational fishing. The buffer zone will surround the core protection zone and will be subject to some restrictions on fishing activities. However, some types of fishing will still be allowed in this area, including lobster and crab fishing using traps.

The establishment of the Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons has been met with mixed reactions from different groups. Environmental organizations and scientists have praised the decision as an important step towards protecting the region’s unique and endangered marine ecosystems. The fishing industry, on the other hand, has expressed concerns over the economic impact of the decision.

The fishing industry in Nova Scotia is an important source of employment and income for many communities, particularly in rural areas. The establishment of the marine refuge will mean that some fishermen will no longer be able to fish in the affected areas, which could have a significant impact on their livelihoods. However, the government has promised to provide compensation to affected fishermen and to work with them to transition to more sustainable fishing practices.

The establishment of the Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons is part of a larger effort to protect Canada’s oceans and ensure the sustainability of its fisheries. In recent years, there has been growing concern over the impact of human activities on marine ecosystems, including overfishing, pollution, and climate change. The establishment of marine protected areas, like the Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons, is seen as an important tool for addressing these challenges.

Marine protected areas are designated areas of the ocean that are set aside for conservation and sustainable use. They are designed to protect important marine ecosystems and species, while also allowing for some types of human activities, such as fishing and tourism. Marine protected areas can be established at the national, regional, or local level, and can take a variety of different forms, from fully protected “no-take” zones to areas with more flexible management plans.

The benefits of marine protected areas are many. They provide important habitats for endangered and threatened species, help to maintain healthy marine ecosystems and support sustainable fisheries. They also provide opportunities for scientific research and monitoring, which can help us to better understand the impacts of human activities on the ocean and inform more effective conservation strategies.

The establishment of the Cape Breton Marine Refuge Eastern Canyons is an important step towards protecting Canada’s oceans and ensuring the sustainability of its fisheries. It is a testament to the importance of collaboration and partnerships between conservationists, governments and local stakeholders.

[xyz-ihs snippet=”Prepared-by-PK”]

Feature Destination

Feature Destination: Ocean Conservation in Nova Scotia

Nova Scotia, a beautiful province on the east coast of Canada, has a rich marine biodiversity that needs to be preserved and protected for future generations and to maintain the balance of surrounding ecosystems. The province’s location along the Atlantic Ocean with vast coastlines provides a unique opportunity for ocean conservation efforts. Over the years, various organizations, governments, and communities have made significant steps towards protecting Nova Scotia’s biodiversity.

One of the most significant conservation efforts in Nova Scotia is the establishment of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), to conserve and protect marine life and ecosystems. Nova Scotia is home to five MPAs, each with unique ecological features and protected species. The MPAs are the Gully, St. Anns Bank, Georges Bank, Fundy, and Eastern Shore Islands. These areas protect critical habitats for endangered species, such as leatherback turtles, North Atlantic right whales, and Atlantic salmon. The federal and provincial governments have worked together to establish these MPAs, and they are managed through various partnerships between government, industry, and conservation groups.

A large conservation movement in Nova Scotia has been the protection of marine mammals, particularly the endangered North Atlantic right whale. These whales are one of the world’s most endangered species, and the waters off Nova Scotia are critical breeding and feeding grounds for them. In recent years, the government of Canada has implemented several measures to protect the North Atlantic right whale. These measures include reducing the speed of ships in critical whale habitats, rerouting shipping lanes, and implementing fishing restrictions in areas where the whales are known to feed. These measures have resulted in a significant reduction in the number of whale deaths due to entanglements and collisions with ships.

The Nova Scotia government has also implemented several initiatives to promote sustainable fishing practices. The province’s fishing industry is a significant contributor to the local economy, but overfishing and unsustainable practices can harm the marine ecosystem. To address this issue, the government has established fisheries management plans that regulate fishing activities, including quotas, closed areas, and gear restrictions. These plans are developed in partnership with industry, Indigenous groups, and conservation groups, and they aim to ensure that fishing practices are sustainable and do not harm the marine environment.

In addition to government-led efforts, various conservation groups and organizations are also working towards ocean conservation in Nova Scotia. One such group is the Ecology Action Centre (EAC), a non-profit organization that works towards sustainable solutions to environmental issues. The EAC has several programs focused on marine conservation, including their Ocean Program and Sustainable Seafood Program. The Ocean Program focuses on ocean protection, with a focus on MPAs and sustainable fishing practices. The Sustainable Seafood Program works with local fishermen and seafood businesses to promote sustainable fishing practices and educate consumers about sustainable seafood choices.

Another organization working towards ocean conservation in Nova Scotia is the Marine Animal Response Society (MARS). MARS is a non-profit organization that responds to marine animal strandings, including whales, seals, and turtles. The organization’s work is critical in understanding the health of marine species and identifying potential threats to their survival. MARS also educates the public about marine conservation issues and works with the fishing industry to reduce the risk of accidental entanglements.

Most importantly, community-based conservation efforts are also significant in Nova Scotia. Several coastal communities in the province have established community-led conservation initiatives, such as beach cleanups, shoreline restoration, and education programs. These initiatives are essential in raising awareness about ocean conservation issues and encouraging individuals to take action to protect the marine environment.

Nova Scotia’s ocean conservation efforts are significant and growing, with various organizations, governments, and communities working towards preserving the province’s marine biodiversity. The establishment of MPAs, protection of endangered species, sustainable fishing practices, and community-led conservation initiatives are all essential in ensuring that the province’s marine ecosystem is protected.